Front of box 1 : white half circle is open part of container to see biscuits
Back of box one: I thought the back of the original box was good, but if you unified the dog on the front with the dog on the back I think it would keep the buyer more engaged.
Box 2 front: I thought bringing a all black package was an Idea to change. (Not sticking with this plan)
Box three front: I wanted to see if having a dog on the front and back was cliche. So this package design has no dogs.
box three back




